August 26, 2023

Pre Purchase vs Post Purchase Upsell: Which One Is Better?

Learn all about Post Purchase vs Pre Purchase upsell.

Setup Facebook Pixel on Shopify

In the world of commerce, the pursuit of increased revenue and enhanced customer experiences is a perpetual endeavor. One strategic approach that businesses often employ to achieve these goals is upselling.

Upselling involves encouraging customers to purchase higher-priced items or additional products or services that complement their initial purchase.

Two primary stages for implementing upselling strategies are pre-purchase and post-purchase. But the question arises: which one is better?

In this article, we'll delve into the nuances of pre-purchase and post-purchase upselling to help you decide which strategy aligns best with your business objectives.

Pre Purchase Upsell

Pre-purchase upselling refers to offering customers an upgraded or enhanced version of a product or a bundle of related items before they finalize their initial purchase.


  1. Higher Initial Cart Value: By suggesting premium or value-packed options before the customer completes their purchase, you can increase the average transaction value. This upfront increase in revenue can be advantageous.
  2. Informed Decisions: Pre-purchase upselling allows customers to consider their options thoroughly before making a choice, leading to a sense of empowerment and informed decision-making.
  3. Enhanced Customer Experience: If the upsell genuinely adds value and meets the customer's needs, it can contribute to a positive shopping experience, fostering loyalty and repeat business.


  1. Potential Cart Abandonment: There's a risk that customers might be overwhelmed by options or perceive the upsell as pushy, leading to cart abandonment if not executed delicately.
  2. Negative Perception: If not presented appropriately, pre-purchase upsells could come across as opportunistic, potentially damaging the brand's reputation.

Post Purchase Upsell

Post-purchase upselling involves suggesting additional products or services to customers after they have completed their initial purchase.


  1. Relevancy: Post-purchase upsells can be highly tailored to the customer's preferences based on their recent purchase, increasing the likelihood of acceptance.
  2. Enhanced Customer Relationship: By engaging with customers after their initial purchase, you demonstrate that your brand cares about their needs and seeks to provide ongoing value.
  3. Lower Risk of Cart Abandonment: Since the customer has already completed their primary purchase, there's no risk of jeopardizing that transaction due to upsell suggestions.


  1. Timing: The challenge with post-purchase upselling lies in finding the right moment to introduce additional offers without disrupting the customer's experience or appearing intrusive.
  2. Conversion Rate: Post-purchase upsells might have a lower conversion rate compared to pre-purchase upsells due to the customer already having made their main purchase.

Choosing the Right Strategy

The decision between pre-purchase and post-purchase upselling depends on various factors, including the nature of your business, customer behavior, and the products or services you offer. Here are some guidelines to help you make an informed choice:

  • Product Complexity: If your products require explanation or comparison, pre-purchase upselling might be more effective as customers can evaluate their options before committing.
  • Customer Relationship: Post-purchase upselling is conducive to fostering long-term relationships. If your business focuses on retention and repeat business, this approach could be more suitable.
  • Customer Behavior: Analyze your customer data to understand when they are most receptive to upsells. This can help you time your upsell offers effectively.
  • Value Addition: Regardless of the strategy, the key is to offer genuine value. An upsell should make the customer feel that their purchase is enhanced, not just more expensive.
  • A/B Testing: Experiment with both strategies and analyze the results. A/B testing can reveal which approach yields better conversion rates and revenue.

Closing Thoughts

In conclusion, the battle between pre-purchase and post-purchase upselling isn't about declaring a definitive winner. Both strategies have their merits and challenges. The optimal approach hinges on aligning the upselling strategy with your brand's values, customer preferences, and overall business goals. By striking the right balance, you can unlock the potential for increased revenue and enriched customer relationships.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Don't miss out on expert e-commerce and marketing insights! Subscribe to our newsletter for valuable tips in just a few clicks.

August 26, 2023